Legal Analysis of Legal Power and Legal Protection in Informed Consent Practices in High-Risk Surgical Procedures in Hospitals
Abstract
This research examines the legal force and protective function of informed consent in high-risk surgical procedures, focusing particularly on the latest regulatory framework in Indonesia as stipulated by Law Number 17 of 2023 concerning Health. Currently, there is a notable absence of specific scholarly examination addressing this issue comprehensively. Although the regulation clearly defines patients’ rights to comprehensive medical information and mandates healthcare providers to deliver it transparently, practical ambiguities remain regarding the extent of informed consent’s binding legal authority and effectiveness in providing legal protection for both patients and medical professionals. Employing a normative juridical approach with descriptive-analytical methods, the study is primarily based on literature review and analysis of relevant Supreme Court decisions. The central objective of this research is to evaluate the legal enforceability and protective role of informed consent within the context of high-risk surgical treatments. The findings reveal that informed consent possesses substantial legal force derived from contractual principles established between patients and healthcare providers, thereby ensuring mutual legal protection during high-risk medical procedures. Informed consent encompasses preventive measures that aimed at averting potential disputes through clear communication, and repressive measures, which offer legal remedies in cases of violation, thus strengthening accountability and legal certainty within healthcare services.
References
Aaron, D. G., Robertson, C. T., King, L. P., & Sage, W. M. (2025). A new legal standard for medical malpractice. JAMA, 333(13), 1161–1165.
Alderson, P., Bellsham-Revell, H., Dedieu, N., King, L., Mendizabal, R., & Sutcliffe, K. (2023). Children’s understanding and consent to heart surgery: Multidisciplinary teamwork and moral experiences. Journal of Child Health Care, 27(2), 197–211.
Arlette, J. P., Froese, A. L., & Singh, J. K. (2022). Soft tissue filler therapy and informed consent: a Canadian review. Journal of Cutaneous Medicine and Surgery, 26(1), 50–56.
Cohen, I. G., & Slottje, A. (2024). Artificial intelligence and the law of informed consent. Research Handbook on Health, AI and the Law, 167–182.
Drabiak, K. (2022b). Leveraging law and ethics to promote safe and reliable AI/ML in healthcare. Frontiers in Nuclear Medicine, 2, 983340.
Everett, S. M., Triantafyllou, K., Hassan, C., Mergener, K., Tham, T. C., Almeida, N., Antonelli, G., Axon, A., Bisschops, R., & Bretthauer, M. (2023). Informed consent for endoscopic procedures: European Society of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy (ESGE) position statement. Endoscopy, 55(10), 952–966.
Fraser, A. G., Biasin, E., Bijnens, B., Bruining, N., Caiani, E. G., Cobbaert, K., Davies, R. H., Gilbert, S. H., Hovestadt, L., & Kamenjasevic, E. (2023). Artificial intelligence in medical device software and high-risk medical devices–a review of definitions, expert recommendations and regulatory initiatives. Expert Review of Medical Devices, 20(6), 467–491.
Gabay, G., & Bokek-Cohen, Y. (2019). Infringement of the right to surgical informed consent: negligent disclosure and its impact on patient trust in surgeons at public general hospitals–the voice of the patient. BMC Medical Ethics, 20, 1–13.
Habib, T., Richa, K., & Abou-Mrad, F. (2021). Challenges of the informed consent in some countries of the MENA region: A literature review. Ethics, Medicine and Public Health, 19, 100706.
Jang, S. G., Lee, W., Ha, J., & Choi, S. (2024). Is physical restraint unethical and illegal?: a qualitative analysis of Korean written judgments. BMC Nursing, 23(1), 94.
Karampalis, C., Stamiris, S., Sarridimitriou, A., Stamiris, D., Anestiadou, E., Kakoulidis, P., Sarafis, P., Xatzianestiadou, X., Christodoulou, P., & Vrangalas, V. (2025). Effect of surgical treatment on mental health, disability and quality of life in active military and law enforcement personnel with non-specific chronic low back pain: A retrospective study. International Journal of Orthopaedic and Trauma Nursing, 101183.
Lam, K., Abràmoff, M. D., Balibrea, J. M., Bishop, S. M., Brady, R. R., Callcut, R. A., Chand, M., Collins, J. W., Diener, M. K., & Eisenmann, M. (2022). A Delphi consensus statement for digital surgery. NPJ Digital Medicine, 5(1), 100.
Loeff, D. S., & Shakhsheer, B. A. (2021). The ethics of informed consent and shared decision-making in pediatric surgery. Seminars in Pediatric Surgery, 30(5), 151101.
Long, K. L., Ingraham, A. M., Wendt, E. M., Saucke, M. C., Balentine, C., Orne, J., & Pitt, S. C. (2021). Informed consent and informed decision-making in high-risk surgery: a quantitative analysis. Journal of the American College of Surgeons, 233(3), 337–345.
Mubarak, R. H., & Zarzani, T. R. (2024). Legal Review of the Implementation of Informed Consent in High-Risk Medical Procedures in Indonesia Based on Health Law No. 17 of 2023. Law Sinergy Conference, 1(1), 263–271.
Naik, N., Hameed, B. M., Shetty, D. K., Swain, D., Shah, M., Paul, R., Aggarwal, K., Ibrahim, S., Patil, V., & Smriti, K. (2022). Legal and ethical consideration in artificial intelligence in healthcare: who takes responsibility? Frontiers in Surgery, 9, 862322.
Padovano, M., Scopetti, M., Tomassi, R., Manetti, F., D’Errico, S., Santurro, A., De Toma, G., Frati, P., Miccoli, P., & Fineschi, V. (2022). Mapping complications in thyroid surgery: statistical data are useful for medico-legal management of a recurrent safety issue. Updates in Surgery, 74(5), 1725–1732.
Park, H. J. (2024). Patient perspectives on informed consent for medical AI: A web-based experiment. Digital Health, 10, 20552076241247936.
Pham, T. (2025). Ethical and legal considerations in healthcare AI: innovation and policy for safe and fair use. Royal Society Open Science, 12(5), 241873.
Quach, W. T., Vittetoe, K. L., & Langerman, A. (2023). Ethical and legal considerations for recording in the operating room: a systematic review. Journal of Surgical Research, 288, 118–133.
Raza, F., & Neuberger, J. (2022). Consent in organ transplantation: putting legal obligations and guidelines into practice. BMC Medical Ethics, 23(1), 69.
Rougereau, G., Marty-Diloy, T., Bonaccorsi, R., Vialle, R., Boisrenoult, P., Pascal-Moussellard, H., & Langlais, T. (2023). Malpractice litigation after spinal surgery: a review of allegations in France in 1990–2020. Orthopaedics & Traumatology: Surgery & Research, 109(2), 103510.
Shenoy, A., Shenoy, G. N., & Shenoy, G. G. (2022). Informed consent: Legalities, perspectives of physicians and patients, and practices in OECD/non-OECD countries. Médecine Palliative, 21(1), 11–19.
Sundari, S., Silitonga, S., & Ningrum, A. D. A. (2022). The Legal Power of Informed Consent as A Valid Evidence in Cases of Alleged Malpractice in Terms of Civil Law. LEGAL BRIEF, 11(2), 520–548.
Sutarno, S., & Maryati, M. (2021). Information of medical malpractice and risks in the informed consent process before surgery in Indonesia. Yustisia, 10(2), 269–290.
Tiolince, T. (2023). Indonesian Telemedicine Regulation to Provide Legal Protection for Patient. Journal of Sustainable Development and Regulatory Issues (JSDERI), 1(2), 75–97.
Ursin, F., Timmermann, C., Benzinger, L., Salloch, S., & Tietze, F.-A. (2024a). Intraoperative application of mixed and augmented reality for digital surgery: a systematic review of ethical issues. Frontiers in Surgery, 11, 1287218.
Ursin, F., Timmermann, C., Benzinger, L., Salloch, S., & Tietze, F.-A. (2024b). Intraoperative application of mixed and augmented reality for digital surgery: a systematic review of ethical issues. Frontiers in Surgery, 11, 1287218.
Van Kolfschooten, H. (2022). EU regulation of artificial intelligence: Challenges for patients’ rights. Common Market Law Review, 59(1).
Yi, M., Cao, Y., Zhou, Y., Cao, Y., Zheng, X., Wang, J., Chen, W., Wei, L., & Zhang, K. (2022). Association between hospital legal constructions and medical disputes: a multi-center analysis of 130 tertiary hospitals in Hunan Province, China. Frontiers in Public Health, 10, 993946.
Zheng, J., Lu, Y., Li, W., Zhu, B., Yang, F., & Shen, J. (2023). Prevalence and determinants of defensive medicine among physicians: a systematic review and meta-analysis. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 35(4), mzad096.
Copyright (c) 2025 International Journal of Science and Society
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
.png)
.jpg)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
1.png)
.jpg)
-modified.png)
-modified.png)
-modified.png)
